
Prevention is Better than the Cure
A Clearer Approach to Disclosure
Flaxmans are delighted to be working alongside our friends at BIBA in producing a discussion document for the industry, under the title, A Clearer Approach to Disclosure. Here Michael Wilson explains why
Policy Voidance is exciting!

Well we think it is. The insurance company I worked for (many years ago) used to employ a team of Accident Prevention Surveyors. Their purpose was self-evident from the job title: to minimise accidents, primarily leading to liability claims, arising from the sort of incident for which the chances of occurrence could be reduced through careful management on the part of the Insured. Their presence on the Insured’s premises was usually welcomed, as they were an agreeable and helpful bunch, recruited not only for their technical expertise, but also their ‘people skills’. The Insured viewed them as a genial uncle whose advice was listened to and embraced. It worked.
Here at Flaxmans, we are not normally associated with Accident Prevention. We tend to be consulted generally when things go wrong: a rejected claim; a ‘stuck’ claim going nowhere; a voided policy. We’re happy to help with any of these, but get particularly excited when we hear of a policy voidance.
You would be forgiven for feeling a policy voidance isn’t particularly exciting, and a broker’s client would doubtless come up with a somewhat more colourful adjective!
The reason we find a policy voidance exciting is that it throws us in at the deep end of a policyholder’s experience of dealing with their insurance provider, which frequently exposes bad practice. That can be bad practice on the part of the insurance business; it can, of course, also reveal bad practice on the part of the Insured. It is the getting to the heart of the matter that we find exciting because it presents an opportunity to achieve justice. That isn’t always justice for the Insured against the insurer, though.
Just answer the question!

The heart of the matter often starts at the Proposal Form or Statement of Fact (SoF). It’s a simple matter, isn’t it? The underwriter sets out specific information required to assess the risk; all the Insured has to do is answer the questions. If honest and accurate answers were always provided, there would be little opportunity for voidance. (This is not the place to discuss the wider obligation to make a fair presentation of the risk. Contact us if you are concerned about this, and we will point you in the direction of one or more of our CII webinars).
We have no truck with potential policyholders who know full well there are features of their risk which are unattractive to insurers but bend the truth to their advantage or conveniently overlook their chequered past to secure a palatable premium. But there are times when the questions posed are not as clear as they should be. This has two possible results: the Insured either doesn’t understand the question so, unwittingly, the answer is wrong; or the ambiguity attracts the less-desirable customer who is on the lookout for an advantageous loophole. This militates against a proper working of a contract of insurance.
Clarity is the best way to defeat ambiguity. This is important for insurers because the courts will treat any ambiguity in how the insurer poses the question against the insurer, giving the Insured the benefit of the doubt. So clarity is the word.

A Better Way
We frequently encounter unclear and/or ambiguous questions posed by the insurer. Although such ambiguity can assist us if we feel a voidance should be reversed, both the insurer and the Insured would be better served if the ambiguity could be avoided in the first place. Prevention is Better than the Cure.
A Clearer Approach to Disclosure. (Click here) represents just the initial steps along what might prove to be quite a long road.
In this document, we focus on the need for clarity with specific reference to:
- Insolvency events
- Criminal convictions
- Cancelled or voided policies
We also take the view that, for fairness, cancelled or voided policies should only need to be disclosed going back up to five years; otherwise, the penalties for a cancelled policy can prove more onerous than for a criminal conviction (where most crimes become spent under the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974).
So if you come across examples of poorly worded questions, please send them along to us. We need more excitement!


